Sunday, September 30, 2012

Give diversity a chance


The other day, I read John Heilemann’s article about Joe Biden in New York Magazine. It was a fair article, balancing the gaffs with his mettle and making the point that you have to give Joe a chance to prove himself, because, as we all know, Joe Biden will sometimes say stupid things.
In the beginning of his term – remember? – he several times made us cringe, especially when he said that, “it will not be six months before the world tests Barack Obama” with a “generated crisis.”  But, despite a difficult start with the president, there was a thaw and the two gradually developed a bond.
Heileman writes, “Over time, a sense of personal chemistry has flowered alongside professional esteem.” Biden is quoted as saying, “I think the bottom line is, what they like about Barack is Barack doesn’t pretend to be what he’s not, and I don’t pretend to be what I’m not.” “We’re an unmatched matched pair,” he concludes. The president gave him a chance; I suppose they gave each other a chance.
Likewise, take Kelly Ripa and Michael Strahan. They gave each other a chance, too. Michael guest-hosted until he could get past the blond bubbliness.
Look at the Ramones. Despite Johnny being the punk version of Ted Nugent and Joey being an OCD Jewish liberal, they found a rhythm, gave themselves the same last name and made beautiful music together. (Compare that to the Osmonds, where Donny and Marie share chromo somatic vanilla for DNA, yet we want to beat them with a baseball bat as soon as they smile.)
A few years ago, I had this creative department with a Thai girl, a Korean, a Mexican, two African Americans, an Indian from India, an inked up creative manager, 3 Jews, a bald German that looked like Mussolini, 2 Italians (moi included), 3 maybe 4 gay people and then, get this, I went and hired a white guy who was born in Connecticut, of all places. It turns out that he was, as one of the copywriters described, the “darkest white guy” we had ever met. Sure, he occasionally turned up the collar of his polo shirt, but he had enough good taste in his sick sense of humor to compensate.
         You see, to make diversity pay off, people need a chance. HR charges us with making our agencies more diverse yet rarely are we told what it will take to work, rarely told how to evaluate a young person’s site for potential, rarely told how diversity could do more than make a holding company look good. We need mentorship programs, we need managers who are fascinated by people who think differently than themselves, heck, we need managers. We need to do something other than find different looking kids and plop them into agencies as if from an alien ship. Fine, there is no amount of tutelage that will sway me into hiring a fan of Josh Groban for the creative department (my tolerance has limits) but I do believe a little guidance will go a long way.
         It usually takes time to learn that we share a quality with someone who is quite different, takes time to assimilate that strange quality with the qualities we’ve been comfortable with. Yeah, maybe the tension is all within our selves. Remember Jekyll and Hyde? People need a little help to get over themselves.

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Yeats said it first and I'm okay with that.

    Since writing my last post, "Two Nudes", I came across this quote that sums up how I feel about most of the work coming out of ad agencies, work that rarely gets below the surface.

            The woods of Arcady are dead,
            And over is their antique joy;
            Of old the world on dreaming fed;
            Great truth is now her painted toy. 
   
    Damn, that's good.
    I thought of that nice Levi's film that quoted Walt Whitman's "O Pioneers" and that Volvo ad several years ago that quoted Kerouac's "On The Road." Sometimes it's better to let someone else do the writing. Let the best set of words win.